Change imageIndex after initialization causes flickering

[matthewma7]

If the imageIndex changed when being visible, the component will flicker.
It looks like it's caused by the key change by this line.
I am wondering why the key is needed.

[Ace000001]

@matthewma7 Hi! did you find the solution to this yet?

[altany]

Same here. Any solution by anyone?
@matthewma7 I believe the key is added to fix the issue reported in this thread facebook/react-native#9195 (comment)

Try removing it and you'll probably see the image does not update.

[Ace000001]

@altany only solution i found is not to change the state variable which is being used by imageIndex property. But if you must change the imageIndex while the viewer is visible, unfortunately flicker is there and they haven't fixed it yet.

[Leleka14]

for me it forked to randomly assign imageIndex only once when component is mounted and if image is changed, it only takes to refresh screen, may not be the best solution, but at least image is not flickering

const randomValue = useMemo(()=>Math.random(), [])

<Image src={{uri: https://image/image.jpg?id={randomValue}}}/>

[VasimSegwitz]

@matthewma7 @Ace000001 @altany have you got any success on this issue ?

[Cnilton]

After some tests, I verified that by removing the onImageIndexChange prop the flickering stops.

[AmitDigga]

Reading @altany comment, I think imageIndex actually works like inititalImageIndex, meaning it should not be changed.

1. If your starting image index is startIndex, then pass that imageIndex={startIndex}, but then do not change this startIndex value. Previously i was updating startIndex also on onImageIndexChange={(index)=>setStartIndex(index)} which was causing flickering
2. Now i am using another variable for onImageIndexChange={(index)=>setCurrentIndex(index)}, and using currentIndex to update header and footers.

[hrdyjan1]

This solution meets my needs. Just make sure not to use a dynamic imageIndex.

import React from 'react';
import {Text, StyleSheet} from 'react-native';
import ImageView from 'react-native-image-viewing';

/**
 * Props for the PhotoGallery component.
 */
interface Props {
  currentIndex: number;
  images: {uri: string}[];
  onRequestClose: () => void;
  onImageIndexChange: (index: number) => void;
}

export function PhotoGallery(props: Props) {
  const [index] = React.useState(props.currentIndex);

  return (
    <ImageView
      visible
      imageIndex={index}
      images={props.images}
      onRequestClose={props.onRequestClose}
      HeaderComponent={PhotoGalleryHeader}
      onImageIndexChange={props.onImageIndexChange}
    />
  );
}

type PhotoGalleryHeader = React.ComponentProps<typeof ImageView>['HeaderComponent'];

const PhotoGalleryHeader: PhotoGalleryHeader = ({imageIndex}) => (
  <Text style={styles.whiteText}>Image Number - {imageIndex + 1}</Text>
);

const styles = StyleSheet.create({whiteText: {color: 'white', textAlign: 'center', marginTop: 10}});

[pitops]

Such a trivial bug and still not fixed. I want to create a gallery type of image viewing but this bug makes this useless.