The volume is stuck and does not change on DLNA players

[sp0ngeboobs]

What version of Music Assistant has the issue?

2.0.0b136

What version of the Home Assistant Integration have you got installed?

2024.3.6

Have you tried everything in the Troubleshooting FAQ and reviewed the Open and Closed Issues and Discussions to resolve this yourself?

• Yes

The problem

The sound level is displayed incorrectly.

1. When I change the sound in HA, the volume of the speakers changes, but the slider is stuck at one level. Also, the level in MA is stuck.
2. When I change the sound level in MA, then the slider remains in the right position, but when I load the page, the sound level is not correct, it is taken from HA.

as I understand MA always takes the sound level from HA player attributes ( volume_level: ) which are always at the same level. And if you set a level ( volume_level: ) in developer tools, it will be stuck at that level in the future.

How to reproduce

try changing the sound level in HA and MA

Music Providers

DLNA

Player Providers

radio stream from URL
Soundcloud.

Full log output

I am attaching the log, but there is nothing displayed about the sound level.
log.txt

Additional information

No response

What version of Home Assistant Core are your running

2024.4.3

What type of installation are you running?

Home Assistant OS

On what type of hardware are you running?

Raspberry Pi

[OzGav]

Do you have other players that do work?

[sp0ngeboobs]

Do you have other players that do work?

Yes. I have 6 DLNA players in MA and all of them have such a glitch.
I also have a HomePod connected via an Apple TV add-on, the sound level there works fine.

[OzGav]

Please adjust the title then to properly reflect that this is only a DLNA issue

[marcelveldt]

I am super confused. You say you are using DLNA players but you're talking about HA attributes ?
Which one is it, dlna player in MA or HA players ?

[sp0ngeboobs]

I am super confused. You say you are using DLNA players but you're talking about HA attributes ? Which one is it, dlna player in MA or HA players ?

DLNA music provider in MA.
MA creates an entity (media_player.name ) in HA, in which there is volume_level: in the attributes, and this level does not change through the MA or lovelace interface, it is stuck on one value. But the sound in the speakers changes

[marcelveldt]

Most probably your player is not sending any state changes then after a volume change (DLNA is an awfully flawed protocol)

The log you shared above, is that collected after you tried changing the volume ?

[sp0ngeboobs]

Most probably your player is not sending any state changes then after a volume change (DLNA is an awfully flawed protocol)

The log you shared above, is that collected after you tried changing the volume ?

the fact is that this glitch did not exist before. I noticed this about a month ago.
Yes, I recorded the log when I changed the sound level several times, so there in the log I see the entries "Handling command cmd_volume_set for player"

[sp0ngeboobs]

ok, I tried to connect the player via DLNA integration in HA, created a new entity. And the glitch with the sound continues, so I conclude that maybe it's not a MA problem. Close the topic or let it be?

[OzGav]

If you are happy it is not MA then yes we will close